SOUND PROJECTIONS
AN ONLINE QUARTERLY MUSIC MAGAZINE
EDITOR: KOFI NATAMBU
SPRING, 2019
VOLUME SEVEN NUMBER ONE
WADADA LEO SMITH
Featuring the Musics and aesthetic Visions of:
CINDY BLACKMAN
(March 23-29)
RUTH BROWN
(March 30-April 5)
JOHN LEWIS
(April 6-12)
JULIUS EASTMAN
(April 13-19)
PUBLIC ENEMY
(April 20-26)
WALLACE RONEY
(April 27-May 3)
MODERN JAZZ QUARTET
(May 4-10)
DE LA SOUL
(May 11-17)
KATHLEEN BATTLE
(May 18-24)
JULIA PERRY
(May 25-31)
HALE SMITH
(June 1-7)
BIG BOY CRUDUP
(June 9-15)
With her captivating lyric soprano voice, Kathleen Battle was among the most acclaimed figures in contemporary opera.
Kathleen Battle
(b. August 13, 1948)
Artist Biography by Richard LeSueur
One of the most famous African-American sopranos, Kathleen Battle
received her vocal training at the Cincinnati College Conservatory,
where she studied voice with Franklin Bens and also worked with Italo
Tajo. While at Cincinnati she came to the attention of conductor Thomas Schippers who brought her to the Spoleto Festival in South Carolina to sing the Brahms Requiem in 1972. She made her stage debut in Rossini's Il barbiere di Siviglia as Rosina with the Michigan Opera Theater in Detroit in 1975. Susanna in Mozart's Le nozze di Figaro was her New York City Opera debut role in 1976. During this time, she also sang orchestral concerts in New York, Los Angeles, and Cleveland. James Levine brought her to the Metropolitan Opera in New York as the Shepherd in Wagner's
Tannhäuser in 1978, and she appeared frequently at the Met in important
roles until 1994. She first appeared in Europe in 1978 at the Italian
Spoleto Festival, and in 1979 debuted at the Glyndebourne Festival.
Her first appearance at Salzburg was in 1982 at an all-Mozart concert, and she often returned in concert, recital and opera. Her important opera roles at Salzburg were Susanna, Zerlina, and Despina, three Mozart roles with which she has been associated at many opera houses around the world. She has appeared at most of the major opera houses of the world including San Francisco, Chicago, Covent Garden, London, Geneva, Vienna, and Berlin. In 1985, she was the soprano soloist in Mozart's Coronation Mass at St. Peter's Cathedral at the Vatican, in a performance conducted by Herbert von Karajan. She sang Handel's Semele in a highly acclaimed performance in 1985 at Carnegie Hall and later recorded the role. In 1990 she was joined by Jessye Norman for a concert of spirituals which was conducted by James Levine at Carnegie Hall. Although best known for roles in the operas of Mozart and Strauss (Zdenka, Sophie and Zerbinetta), Battle has also had great success in Massenet's Werther, Donizetti's L'elisir d'amore, Don Pasquale, and La fille du regiment, Verdi's Un ballo in maschera and Falstaff and Rossini's Il barbiere di Siviglia and L'Italiana in Algeri. Battle has maintained an active recital career, and her Schubert interpretations are very fine. Her recital programs have also featured songs by Mozart, Strauss, Fauré and Rodrigo.
Kathleen Battle's voice is a high, very pure soprano with great charm. She has excellent technical control, which has allowed her to sing the difficult coloratura roles of Rosina and Zerbinetta though her approach is always more lyric that that of most coloratura sopranos. She is an excellent actress and tries to give full characterization to each of her roles. Several of her best roles were televised live from the Metropolitan Opera, New York and later released on video.
A perfectionist in her own work, Battle became more and more difficult to deal with as her career moved forward. Some felt that her demands were becoming unreasonable, and her behavior became erratic. These difficulties came to public attention when she was dismissed from the Metropolitan Opera in 1994 for "unprofessional conduct." Battle has continued to appear in concert and recital and remains a favorite of the public.
Ms. Battle and Luciano Pavarotti in Donizetti’s “L’Elisir d’Amore” at the Met in 1991.Creditvia Metropolitan Opera Archives
A version of this article appears in print on , on Page C1 of the New York edition with the headline: After 22 Years and Bad Feelings, a Warm Embrace. Order Reprints | Today’s Paper
Mr. Volpe, who recounted the episode of her firing in his memoir in a chapter called “Battle Hymn,” said in a telephone interview that he was pleased to hear of her pending return. “I’m delighted to see that she will be giving a recital at the Met,” he said, “and I send her my best wishes.”
A version of this article appears in print on , on Page C1 of the New York edition with the headline: You’re Unfired: Kathleen Battle Is Returning to the Met. Order Reprints | Today’s Paper
Her first appearance at Salzburg was in 1982 at an all-Mozart concert, and she often returned in concert, recital and opera. Her important opera roles at Salzburg were Susanna, Zerlina, and Despina, three Mozart roles with which she has been associated at many opera houses around the world. She has appeared at most of the major opera houses of the world including San Francisco, Chicago, Covent Garden, London, Geneva, Vienna, and Berlin. In 1985, she was the soprano soloist in Mozart's Coronation Mass at St. Peter's Cathedral at the Vatican, in a performance conducted by Herbert von Karajan. She sang Handel's Semele in a highly acclaimed performance in 1985 at Carnegie Hall and later recorded the role. In 1990 she was joined by Jessye Norman for a concert of spirituals which was conducted by James Levine at Carnegie Hall. Although best known for roles in the operas of Mozart and Strauss (Zdenka, Sophie and Zerbinetta), Battle has also had great success in Massenet's Werther, Donizetti's L'elisir d'amore, Don Pasquale, and La fille du regiment, Verdi's Un ballo in maschera and Falstaff and Rossini's Il barbiere di Siviglia and L'Italiana in Algeri. Battle has maintained an active recital career, and her Schubert interpretations are very fine. Her recital programs have also featured songs by Mozart, Strauss, Fauré and Rodrigo.
Kathleen Battle's voice is a high, very pure soprano with great charm. She has excellent technical control, which has allowed her to sing the difficult coloratura roles of Rosina and Zerbinetta though her approach is always more lyric that that of most coloratura sopranos. She is an excellent actress and tries to give full characterization to each of her roles. Several of her best roles were televised live from the Metropolitan Opera, New York and later released on video.
A perfectionist in her own work, Battle became more and more difficult to deal with as her career moved forward. Some felt that her demands were becoming unreasonable, and her behavior became erratic. These difficulties came to public attention when she was dismissed from the Metropolitan Opera in 1994 for "unprofessional conduct." Battle has continued to appear in concert and recital and remains a favorite of the public.
Review: Kathleen Battle Returns to the Met After 22 Years. It Was Worth the Wait.
After the bitterness of the soprano Kathleen Battle’s
rift with the Metropolitan Opera in 1994, it looked as if she would
never return to the company’s stage. That year, Joseph Volpe, then the
Met’s general manager, in an extraordinarily blunt statement, dismissed
her from a production of Donizetti’s “La Fille du Régiment” for
“unprofessional actions” during rehearsals that were “profoundly
detrimental” to artistic collaborations among cast members. She was
dropped from the Met’s roster for good, it seemed.
But
on Sunday, at the invitation of the current general manager, Peter
Gelb, Ms. Battle was back, not for an opera production (soon after that
1994 incident she turned her attention to recitals) but for a special
concert program she has been presenting in various cities in recent
years, titled “Kathleen Battle: Underground Railroad — A Spiritual
Journey.” The house was sold out. Audience members who had waited 22
years to hear her at the Met had to wait a little longer on Sunday,
because the concert started 40 minutes late. It was worth the delay.
Performing
with an impressive choir called Voices of the Underground Railroad, two
fine pianists and some special guests (including Wynton Marsalis), Ms.
Battle, 68, sang with remarkable freshness and beauty. Even at the
height of her operatic career, her voice
was a light lyric soprano, ideal for roles like Strauss’s Sophie and
Mozart’s Susanna. Yet during those years she sang with such focus and
bloom that her sound had penetrating richness and radiant presence.
For
much of this recital on Sunday her singing had these same special
qualities. There were some breathy passages and slight signs of strain.
But for the most part she sounded wonderful, especially in her lovely
high range. In the spirituals “Lord, How Come Me Here?” and “Let Us
Break Bread Together,” among many others, she sent high phrases soaring
and sang with ethereal elegance.
Ms. Battle and Luciano Pavarotti in Donizetti’s “L’Elisir d’Amore” at the Met in 1991.Creditvia Metropolitan Opera Archives
Her
dismissal from the Met was arguably justified by well-reported
instances of disruptive and petulant behavior. She had similarly
strained relationships with other companies. Yet, during this recital I
kept thinking about what a sad loss her absence has been to opera lovers
in New York and around the world.
When this concert was announced
in April, Ms. Battle said that the program “brings together my musical
background and my cultural heritage.” Born in Portsmouth, Ohio, the
youngest of seven children, she became active as a child
in the music of her African Methodist Episcopal church. After her
training at the University of Cincinnati College-Conservatory of Music,
she began teaching music in grade school. But she was discovered by the
conductor Thomas Schippers, who brought her to the attention of James
Levine, who became a dedicated mentor.
These
spirituals clearly touch her deeply. The focus of the program was the
Underground Railroad, the secret network of “conductors” and “pilots”
who, at enormous risk, helped thousands of slaves in the South find safe
havens and nighttime routes to freedom in the North. Interspersed
between the performances of two dozen spirituals by Ms. Battle and the
34-voice choir (conducted by Stephanie Fisher and Rachel Blackburn),
there were readings by Jussie Smollett (who acted as narrator) and some
choir members of words by Frederick Douglass, Harriet Tubman, the Rev.
Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and other civil rights giants. The great
actress Cicely Tyson, 91, riveted the audience with an excerpt from a
speech by the slave-born abolitionist Sojourner Truth.
The
jazz-infused arrangements of the spirituals were played vibrantly by
the stylish pianist Joel A. Martin and, in some pieces, the pianist
Cyrus Chestnut. Though many arrangements gave solo opportunities to
outstanding singers from the choir, Ms. Battle, of course, was the star.
I was especially moved by the spirituals when she sang with just the
piano, like “City Called Heaven,” in which she conveyed a poignant mix
of longing for the promised city, sadness and childlike innocence.
Ms.
Battle remains a prima donna to her core. Her performances were
sometimes marred by mannerisms and quirks. Like the schoolteacher she
once was, she would hold up a hand to quiet down her pianist, or mouth
words to the chorus or, in a couple of strange moments, direct silent
gestures to people in the audience.
But
this long program, with five encores, was her day, her return. And,
given that audiences at the Met are almost always overwhelmingly white,
it was meaningful to see so many African-Americans in the house. The
final standing ovation was tumultuous.
Correction:
A
music review on Tuesday about “Kathleen Battle: Underground Railroad — A
Spiritual Journey” at the Metropolitan Opera, which included readings,
misidentified the source of the words by Sojourner Truth that were read
by Cicely Tyson. It is a speech she gave in Akron, Ohio, in 1851, not a
memoir. The final sentence of the review was truncated in some editions.
It should have read, “The final standing ovation was tumultuous.”
You’re Unfired: Kathleen Battle
Is Returning to the Met After 22 Years
It
may be the biggest unfiring in opera since Maria Callas’s New York
comeback: Kathleen Battle, a prima donna whose dismissal by the
Metropolitan Opera more than two decades ago made front-page news, will return to the Met next season to sing a recital of spirituals.
The
concert, scheduled for Nov. 13, will provide a burst of old-school star
power at a time when the Met has been struggling with declining
attendance. Arrangements for her appearance came after Ms. Battle, 67,
was courted by Peter Gelb, the company’s general manager. “I think great
artists should be on the stage of the Met,” Mr. Gelb said in an
interview. “There aren’t enough of them.”
Ms. Battle was a Grammy-winning
soprano who had appeared with the Met 224 times by 1994, when Joseph
Volpe, then general manager, fired her from a production of Donizetti’s
“La Fille du Régiment” a week before opening night, citing, with a
bluntness unusual in classical music, her “unprofessional actions during
rehearsals.” Stories quickly circulated about what was described as
divalike behavior and rudeness toward colleagues, including demands that
other singers leave rehearsals when she was singing and not look at her
mouth during duets.
Ms. Battle was
said to arrive late to rehearsals, leave early or not to show up at all.
Nor was “Fille” the first case of her being temperamental: The year
before, she withdrew from a Met production of Strauss’s “Der
Rosenkavalier” after clashing with the conductor. A few months before
that, in a season-opening appearance with the Boston Symphony Orchestra,
she was said to have changed hotels several times and banned an
assistant conductor from her rehearsals.
“I was not told by anyone at the Met
about any unprofessional actions,” she said in a statement after being
fired, adding, “All I can say is I am saddened by this decision.”
Her
dismissal — and return — calls to mind past tempestuous clashes between
opera divas and impresarios. Callas, one of the great sopranos of the
20th century, was fired by the Met
in 1958 after a dispute over which roles she would agree to sing. She,
too, was rehired, in 1965, and returned to give two final Met
performances of “Tosca” that are now considered legendary. (“Kathy
Battle,” Mr. Volpe later recalled telling her manager when he terminated
her contract, “is no Callas.”)
Kathleen Battle in a solo recital at Carnegie Hall in 2008. Credit: Hiroyuki Ito for The New York Times
She
will give a recital called “Kathleen Battle: Underground Railroad — A
Spiritual Journey,” accompanied by Joel Martin on the piano and by a
choir led by James Davis Jr., the director of Music Ministries and Fine
Arts at the Abyssinian Baptist Church in Harlem. Ms. Battle, who has
performed versions of the program in Philadelphia, Detroit and
Baltimore, said that she was excited to bring it to the Met.
“Spirituals
have the power to uplift and to heal, and we certainly need that in
today’s world,” she said in a statement. “This is a program which brings
together my musical background and my cultural heritage, in the
acoustical splendor of the Met.”
Mr. Gelb said
that he had long been trying to get Ms. Battle, who turned away from
staged opera after her firing and has since largely pursued a recital
career, to return to the opera house. “When I first was appointed, I
tried to persuade her to come back to the Met to sing a role in a Mozart
opera,” he said. “But she couldn’t get her head around that.”
Then
he thought about having her bring her “Underground Railroad” program,
and in December Mr. Gelb and Ms. Battle visited the stage together,
configured for a recital with the orchestra pit raised and acoustical
screens put up, to see if she would be comfortable. “She sounded
fantastic, and she said she’d do it,” he said.
Ms.
Battle was born in Portsmouth, Ohio, in 1948, the daughter of a
steelworker father and mother who volunteered at the family’s African
Methodist Episcopal Church. An elementary school music teacher in
Cincinnati before becoming a solo singer, she was championed by James
Levine, who conducted many of her Met performances, including her
company debut in 1977 as the Shepherd in Wagner’s “Tannhäuser.”
On
Feb. 23, 1985, Handel’s 300th birthday, she appeared to great acclaim
in a concert performance of his “Semele” at Carnegie Hall. (“It had to
be,” Donal Henahan wrote in The New York Times, “the performance of her
young and still-blossoming career.”) A smiling natural in Mozart and
Strauss’s ingénue roles, her fresh and pure (if slender) tone and
seemingly effortless agility translated beautifully to recording, and
she eventually became one of Deutsche Grammophon’s biggest stars. But a
reputation for causing backstage strife began to dog her: Colleagues at
the San Francisco Opera were seen wearing T-shirts reading “I Survived
the Battle” after one of her appearances.
Mr. Volpe, who recounted the episode of her firing in his memoir in a chapter called “Battle Hymn,” said in a telephone interview that he was pleased to hear of her pending return. “I’m delighted to see that she will be giving a recital at the Met,” he said, “and I send her my best wishes.”
A version of this article appears in print on , on Page C1 of the New York edition with the headline: You’re Unfired: Kathleen Battle Is Returning to the Met. Order Reprints | Today’s Paper
Kathleen
Battle, the soprano who in recent years has been as famous for her
fiery temperament as for the beauty of her voice, was dismissed
yesterday from the Metropolitan Opera's production of Donizetti's "Fille
du Regiment" for what the company called "unprofessional actions"
during rehearsals.
Several
people involved with the production said that Miss Battle had been
difficult and uncooperative even after rehearsal schedules were changed
to accommodate her demands, and that she had upset other members of the
cast.
In
effect, Miss Battle is being dropped from the Met roster: the
production was the only one for which she was under contract, and Joseph
Volpe, the Met's general manager, said in an interview that when he
dismissed Miss Battle, he "canceled all offers that have been made for
the future." 'Profoundly Detrimental'
In an extraordinary statement from an institution that usually maintains an air of patrician diplomacy, Mr. Volpe said:
"Kathleen
Battle's unprofessional actions during rehearsals for the revival of
'La Fille du Regiment' were profoundly detrimental to the artistic
collaboration among all the cast members, which is such an essential
component of the rehearsal process. I could not allow the quality of the
performance to be jeopardized. I have taken this step to insure that
everyone involved in the production will be able to rehearse and perform
in an atmosphere that makes it possible for them to perform at their
best."
In
a statement released by her management company, Columbia Artists, Miss
Battle said: "I was not told by anyone at the Met about any
unprofessional actions. To my knowledge, we were working out all of the
artistic problems in the rehearsals, and I don't know the reason behind
this unexpected dismissal. All I can say is I am saddened by this
decision."
Mr.
Volpe would not be more specific about his reasons for dismissing Miss
Battle. But several people at the Met, who spoke on condition of
anonymity, said that the problems began when Miss Battle objected to
attending the two or three daily rehearsals that are typical in the
weeks before a production opens. When the schedule was revamped to suit
her, they said, she arrived late, left early or did not show up at all.
She is said to have demanded that other singers leave the rehearsals
when she was singing, and was described as having been "very nasty" to
members of the cast.
The production is to open on Monday with Harolyn Blackwell substituting for Miss Battle.
Almost
exactly a year ago, Miss Battle stormed out of a rehearsal of "Der
Rosenkavalier" at the Met after a dispute with the conductor, Christian
Thielemann, and told Mr. Volpe that if he did not come to her dressing
room to hear her complaints within five minutes, she would withdraw from
the production. Mr. Volpe did not appear, and she quit. Stories
Circulate Quickly
A
few months earlier, when Miss Battle opened the Boston Symphony
Orchestra season, she reportedly banned an assistant conductor and other
musicians from her rehearsals, changed hotels several times, and left
behind what a report in The Boston Globe called "a froth of ill will."
Record executives have complained that her demands to have her cover
photographs retouched or reshot have delayed the release of her
recordings and played havoc with scheduling. Indeed, stories of her
backstage tantrums travel through the music world at lightning speed.
The
current clash recalls the confrontations between Maria Callas and
Rudolf Bing in the late 1950's, particularly Mr. Bing's 1958 public
dismissal of the soprano. But there are differences. The Callas-Bing
dispute was over a contractual point, not over Callas's behavior at
rehearsals. Also, Callas was at the peak of her career. Miss Battle,
who is 45, has lost some of the freshness that once made her so valuable
in ingenue roles.
Disputes
between singers and managers sometimes seem part of the fabric of the
opera world. Maria Ewing, James McCracken and Eva Marton have all
stormed out of the Met when coveted roles or broadcast performances were
given to other singers. But it is rare for a company to publicly
question a star's professionalism. The most famous recent case was
Luciano Pavarotti's dismissal from the Lyric Opera of Chicago in 1989
after a dispute about the frequency of his cancellations.
Miss
Battle was born in Portsmouth, Ohio, and was a music teacher in a
Cincinnati elementary school before she had her earliest break as a
singer. That came in 1972, when she auditioned for Thomas Schippers, the
director of the Cincinnati Symphony and the Spoleto Festival, who hired
her for a series of performances. A year later, James Levine heard her
at the Cincinnati May Festival, and began engaging her when he appeared
as guest conductor around the country.
She
came to New York in 1975 to sing in the Broadway production of Scott
Joplin's opera "Treemonisha," and in 1976 she made her debut at the New
York City Opera, as Susanna in "Le Nozze di Figaro." Mr. Levine brought
her to the Met as the Shepherd in Wagner's "Tannhauser" in 1977. Her
pure, clear tone immediately impressed opera fans starved for
distinctive singing, and she quickly found herself in demand in opera
houses all over the world.
What
effect her dismissal from the Met will have on her career is uncertain.
Her recordings continue to sell in vast quantities, and as one of the
few opera stars who is a household name, she is still a hot commodity at
the box office and consequently is in demand as a soloist.
Mr.
Volpe, when asked whether he was likely to invite Miss Battle back to
the Met, said: "I never say never. I don't want to say that this break
is forever."
A version of this article appears in print on February 8, 1994, on Page A00001 of the National edition with the headline: The Met Drops Kathleen Battle, Citing 'Unprofessional Actions'.
A version of this archives appears in print on October 23, 1975, on Page 47 of the New York edition with the headline: Kathleen Battle Is Standout As ‘Treemonisha’.
People
who go to the matinees of “Treemonisha”—which will move from the Uris
Theater to the Palace Theater on Nov. 4 for a run through Dec. 21—have
no need to feel cheated because the title part isn't being sung by
Carmen Balthrop. Kathleen Battle, her substitute, has a perfectly lovely
lyric soprano that meets the demands of the role with gracious eaase.
It's
a little hard to tell how big the voice is, given the distorted and
clumsily handled amplification. But in relation to the others in the
cast it seems of healthy size, and her timbre, range and artistry are
all that one might ask for. It would be nice to hear her in “real”
operatic roles.
Miss
Battle Is a charmer, dramatically, as well—pert to look at and fully
comfortable in Frank Corsaro's production. There can't be too many
instances, on Broadway or in opera, where an understudy has been of this
quality.
JOHN ROCKWELL
Music